Your Hospitality Industry Trade Secrets May be at Risk

By Steven D. Weber Founder, Weber Law, P.A. | January 22, 2017

The hospitality industry may be able to protect their trade secrets using newly enacted federal legislation. The Defend Trade Secrets Act of 2016 (the “DTSA”) was signed into law on May 11, 2016. The DTSA creates a federal cause of action for an owner of a trade secret that is misappropriated if the trade secret “is related to a product or service used in, or intended for use in, interstate or foreign commerce.” The DTSA also provides a powerful new remedy of allowing ex parte applications for an order allowing the seizure of property necessary to prevent the dissemination of the trade secret that is the subject of the action.

Under the DTSA, a “trade secret” encompasses a wide variety of forms and types of information but only if “(A) the owner thereof has taken reasonable measures to keep such information secret; and (B) the information derives independent economic value, actual or potential, from not being generally known to, and not being readily ascertainable through proper means by, another person who can obtain economic value from the disclosure or use of the information.” Pursuant to the DTSA, prohibited “misappropriation” includes both the acquisition of a trade secret by improper means and the trade secret’s disclosure by a person who knew at the time of disclosure that the knowledge of the trade secret was “derived from or through a person who owed a duty to the person seeking relief to maintain the secrecy of the trade secret, ” or other circumstances. The protections, secrecy measures, and access limitations that a trade secret owner puts in place may determine the rights and remedies afforded them under the DTSA.

The hospitality industry may also be able to take advantage of state law rights and remedies related to trade secrets. The Uniform Trade Secrets Act (“UTSA”) was intended to make uniform the state law regarding theft of trade secrets. One hospitality hot spot, the state of Florida, adopted the UTSA as the Florida Uniform Trade Secrets Act (“FUTSA”). FUTSA provides damages and other relief related to the misappropriation of trade secrets.

Under FUTSA, a trade secret may be (i) information, (2) that derives independent economic value from not being generally known or ascertainable and (3) is the subject of reasonable efforts to maintain its secrecy. For example, in the case Premier Lab Supply, Inc. v. Chemplex Indus., Inc., 10 So. 3d 202, 206 (Fla. 4th DCA 2009), a Florida appellate court found that a thin film spooling machine was properly a trade secret because, inter alia, evidence was presented “that the design of machine is very specific and involves many calculations”, “without access to the machine one would be unable to obtain the required measurements” necessary to reproduce it, the “machine was kept in a separate room away from the public”, and that “only certain individuals who operated the machine were authorized to enter” the room where the machine was stored. Notably, there, the lack of a confidentiality agreement did not defeat the argument that the machine was a trade secret – however, this will not always be the case. Accordingly, the protection a company provides to its hospitality trade secrets could determine whether they are in fact found to be trade secrets.

The need to protect hospitality trade secrets is not merely a hypothetical concern. There are numerous cases that relate to allegations of misappropriation of hospitality trade secrets. In 2009, Starwood Hotels & Resorts Worldwide, Inc. (“Starwood”) sued Hilton Hotels Corporation n/k/a Hilton Worldwide (“Hilton”) and certain individuals alleging that Hilton induced those individuals to leave Starwood and work for Hilton, and that Hilton, the individuals, and others, “stole hundreds of thousands of electronic files and documents constituting confidential and proprietary Starwood information and/or trade secrets [] for use by Hilton across all of Hilton’s luxury and lifestyle brands in direct competition with Starwood.” See Amended Complaint ¶¶ 7, 9, DE 31, Starwood Hotels & Resorts Worldwide, Inc. v. Hilton Hotels Corporation N/K/A Hilton Worldwide, No. 09 Civ. 3862 (S.D.N.Y). Starwood plead a claim of misappropriation of trade secrets (among other claims) and alleged that through the actions of Hilton and the individuals, they knowingly misappropriated and used, or aided and abetted the misappropriation and misuse of, Starwood’s trade secrets.

Although it appears that the parties reached a settlement, a key issue in the case would have been whether the protection that Starwood provided to the information at issue was sufficient to find that the information constituted a trade secret. In Starwood’s complaint, it alleged that the individual defendants signed employment agreements, including a “Non-Solicitation, Confidentiality and Intellectual Property Agreement.” Starwood also alleged that the individuals signed agreements that were “subject to ‘all Starwood policies, procedures and directives as they currently exist or as they may be adopted or changed from time to time, ’ which included Starwood’s Code of Business Conduct, ” which required, among other things, that each employee protect and keep confidential certain non-public information. Starwood further alleged that its data is maintained on secure servers and hard drives, that remote access is permitted only upon proper certification, that employees may not access Starwood’s systems through computers not properly certified by Starwood’s IT staff, and that employees are not permitted to forward confidential materials to outside systems, “including their own homes or personal e-mail accounts.” While the court did not determine whether Starwood’s measures are adequate, this case is a good example of the steps that a company may be required to take to protect its hospitality trade secret information.

Coming up in January 2018...

Mobile Technology: Relentless Innovation

Technology has become a crucial component in attracting and retaining hotel guests, and the need to enhance a guest’s technology experience is driving a relentless pace of innovation. To meet and exceed guest expectations, 54% of hotels will spend more on technology in 2018, and mobile solutions in particular will top the list of capital investments. Many hotels are integrating mobile booking, mobile keys, mobile payments and mobile check-in into their operations. Other hotels are emphasizing the in-room experience, boosting bandwidth and upgrading flat screen TVs to more easily interface with guest mobile devices. And though not yet mainstream, there are many exciting technology developments on the near horizon. The Internet of Things (loT) is taking form in some places, and can be found in guest room control systems, voice activation systems, and in wearable sensors that can be used for access and payment options. Virtual reality headsets are available at some hotels so guests can enjoy virtual trips to exotic locations or if off-property, preview conference facilities and guest rooms. How long will it be before a hotel employs a fleet of robots for room service, or utilizes a hologram as a concierge, or installs gesture-controlled walls that feature interactive digital displays? Some hotels are already using augmented reality for translation services, or interactive wall maps, or even virtual décor. This pace of innovation is challenging property owners and brands to stay on top of the latest technology trends while still addressing current projects. The January Hotel Business Review will explore what some hotels are doing to maximize their opportunities in the mobile technology space.