Do Customer Experience Measures Matter More than Social Media Reviews?

Ratings, Rankings, Reviews and Everything In Between

By Janet Gerhard Partner & CXO, Inquizo | August 04, 2013

Internal vs. External Ratings

Do customer experience rankings compiled by multiple firms really matter? The unfortunate answer, "It depends." Some customer experience measures do matter. Internal ones are used in most accountability programs. Hotel companies spend millions of dollars each year to ensure the validity and reliability of these programs, holding hotels accountable to certain performance thresholds. Many of these quality assurance programs are written into management contracts and are the basis for formally moving hotels out of the brand. Companies differ in their approach to accountability. Some use overall satisfaction as its measure of performance. Others create an index of average overall satisfaction, intent to recommend and intent to return. Still others use a combination of performance metrics deemed important to the brand experience.

New territory is being forged with the onslaught of social media, and its use by hotels is maturing beyond managing reputation and customer retention efforts. Although relatively new to the scene, consumer generated media has high visibility with customers. But, when compared to the millions of traditional surveys collected by the rigor of quality assurance, they are a mere drop in the bucket. Total volume is difficult to calculate and the quality of the consumer generated feedback varies greatly by the source. Many hotels rely on the review sites, but numbers here are thin. And it's even worse if the hotel is not actively engaged in it.

Social media gets more attention because it is publicly available. All too often it is reactionary and primarily an additional channel for customer care. The Cornell study, "The Impact of Social Media on Lodging Performance" is often cited for initial evidence of ROI. The findings show if a hotel increases its review scores by 1 point on TripAdvisor's 5-point scale (e.g., from 3.3 to 4.3), the hotel can increase its price by 11.2% and still maintain the same occupancy or market share. However, moving up an entire point is no easy task unless your hotel has little to no volume of reviews to speak of.

A May 2013 tongue in cheek article titled, "What is the ROI of your (expensive) kids? Should be the same as your hotel guests" by Carla Caccavale, did not speak to specific financial returns but assumed the same tenants of the Service Profit Chain – better experiences brings stronger preference and greater loyalty. With only a small percentage of hotels responding to reviews, there is definitely room for improvement. And, accountability in its traditional sense will fall to engagement, meaning the large hotel brands are likely to track "responsiveness of hotels" as the first item of social media to be measured consistently. Performance, rolled in to a more traditional measure like customer surveys, is already beginning to integrate social sentiment.


Choose a Social Network!

The social network you are looking for is not available.

Coming up in June 2019...

Sales & Marketing: Selling Experiences

There are innumerable strategies that Hotel Sales and Marketing Directors employ to find, engage and entice guests to their property, and those strategies are constantly evolving. A breakthrough technology, pioneering platform, or even a simple algorithm update can cause new trends to emerge and upend the best laid plans. Sales and marketing departments must remain agile so they can adapt to the ever changing digital landscape. As an example, the popularity of virtual reality is on the rise, as 360 interactive technologies become more mainstream. Chatbots and artificial intelligence are also poised to become the next big things, as they take guest personalization to a whole new level. But one sales and marketing trend that is currently resulting in major benefits for hotels is experiential marketing - the effort to deliver an experience to potential guests. Mainly this is accomplished through the creative use of video and images, and by utilizing what has become known as User Generated Content. By sharing actual personal content (videos and pictures) from satisfied guests who have experienced the delights of a property, prospective guests can more easily imagine themselves having the same experience. Similarly, Hotel Generated Content is equally important. Hotels are more than beds and effective video presentations can tell a compelling story - a story about what makes the hotel appealing and unique. A video walk-through of rooms is essential, as are video tours in different areas of a hotel. The goal is to highlight what makes the property exceptional, but also to show real people having real fun - an experience that prospective guests can have too. The June Hotel Business Review will report on some of these issues and strategies, and examine how some sales and marketing professionals are integrating them into their operations.