Off the Clock Shouldn't Mean Off the Paycheck: De Minimis Time in California

By Dana Kravetz Firm Managing Partner, Michelman & Robinson, LLP | November 11, 2018

Thirty years ago – nearly a decade before I was sworn in as a member of the bar – I had a job bussing tables at a swanky restaurant in beautiful Del Mar, California. I showed up for work on Friday and Saturday nights – and Sundays for brunch – and made myself busy clearing plates, utensils, wine glasses and anything else diners wanted out of their way. The tips were nothing to sneeze at, and I couldn't have asked for a better part-time gig while in college in San Diego. 

But there was something about the job that makes me scratch my head all these years later. On my night shifts, I closed the restaurant and was the last to leave. Yet before heading home, my responsibilities included bundling up trash from the kitchen and hauling the bags to dumpsters located on the opposite end of the building. Separately, I had to spray off the rubber mats that covered the kitchen floor and hang them over an outside railing to dry overnight. Here's the rub. I wasn't to do any of these tasks – which took me about 10 minutes, max – without first clocking out, setting the restaurant's alarm and locking up.

Week in and week out, the same routine: punch the clock, ready the alarm, close the locked kitchen door behind me and hustle outside with my trash and mats. Never, however, was I compensated for this de minimis time. Fast forward and I'm now a longtime hospitality and management-side employment lawyer, and in the wake of the recent ruling in Troester v. Starbucks Corporation – in which the California Supreme Court determined that employees who routinely handle off-the-clock tasks, no matter how negligible, are entitled to be paid for them – I understand, more than ever, that I was appreciably underpaid way back when.

No doubt about it, Troester is big news for all employers, those in the hotel and resort space included, as employees have new fodder to sue for unpaid de minimis time, now with the backing of the Golden State's highest court.

The Troester Ruling

In Troester, it was held that the so-called "de minimis defense" does not, for the most part, apply to wage claims brought pursuant to the California Labor Code. In the world of employment law, this is mildly earth shattering.  Courts had long viewed the defense, frequently advanced on behalf of employers, as effective in defeating single plaintiff and class action claims for unpaid wages as they related to the seconds or minutes employees spent outside scheduled work hours to change clothes, don or remove safety equipment, turn equipment on or off and the like. No longer is this the case, at least in California.

Choose a Social Network!

The social network you are looking for is not available.


Hotel Newswire Headlines Feed  

Didi Lutz
Jacki Kelley
Brenda Fields
James Gieselman
Bonnie Knutson
Nicholas Tsabourakis
Jeff Guaracino
Naseem Javed
Bill Kotrba
Elaine Fenard
Coming up in January 2019...

Mobile Technology: The Future is Now

Mobile Technology continues to advance at a relentless pace and the hotel industry continues to adapt. Hotel guests have shown a strong preference for mobile self-service - from checking-in/out at a hotel kiosk, to ordering room service, making dinner reservations, booking spa treatments, and managing laundry/dry cleaning services. And they also enjoy the convenience of paying for these services with smart phone mobile payments. In addition, some hotels have adopted a “concierge in your pocket” concept. Through a proprietary hotel app, guests can access useful information such as local entertainment venues, tourist attractions, event calendars, and medical facilities and services. In-room entertainment continues to be a key factor, as guests insist on the capacity to plug in their own mobile devices to customize their entertainment choices. Mobile technology also allows for greater marketing opportunities. For example, many hotels have adopted the use of “push notifications” - sending promotions, discounts and special event messages to guests based on their property location, purchase history, profiles, etc. Near field communication (NFC) technology is also being utilized to support applications such as opening room doors, earning loyalty points, renting a bike, accessing a rental car, and more. Finally, some hotels have adopted more futuristic technology. Robots are in use that have the ability to move between floors to deliver room service requests for all kinds of items - food, beverages, towels, toothbrushes, chargers and snacks. And infrared scanners are being used by housekeeping staff that can detect body heat within a room, alerting staff that the room is occupied and they should come back at a later time. The January Hotel Business Review will report on what some hotels are doing to maximize their opportunities in this exciting mobile technology space.